Show HN rules in 2026: what qualifies, what gets flagged, and how to post without AI-written text
The Show HN rules, quoted from Hacker News's own pages: what qualifies, what gets a post flagged, why AI-written and AI-edited text is out, and how to prepare the try-it link and first comment.
Nihar Rout · · Updated · 10 min read · 53 views
The Show HN rules come down to three tests: you made it, people can try it today, and you wrote the post yourself. Since an edit dated March 28, 2026, dang's Show HN tips also say not to use an LLM for any of the text, not even to edit it. Here is what qualifies, what gets flagged, and what to prepare before you post.
Every rule below is quoted from four Hacker News pages, all read on November 20, 2026: the Show HN guidelines, the site guidelines, the Hacker News FAQ and the tips comment, written by the HN account dang, that the Show HN page links to. Where a popular piece of launch advice is not on those pages, such as a best time to post, we say so rather than fill the gap.
The Show HN rules at a glance
| Rule | Where it is written | What it means for your launch |
|---|---|---|
| Something people can try | Show HN guidelines | Ship a working link, not a promise |
| No blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters or lists | Show HN guidelines | Post those as a regular submission |
| No landing pages or fundraisers | Show HN guidelines | A waitlist is not a Show HN |
| Non-trivial, not a quickly generated one-off | Show HN guidelines | Low-effort one-offs don't qualify |
| Title begins with "Show HN" | Show HN guidelines | The label is the opt-in |
| No asking friends to upvote or comment | Show HN guidelines, FAQ | Penalties reach the site, not only the post |
| No generated text in posts or comments | Site guidelines | Your text and replies are yours |
| No LLM for any of the text, including edits | dang's tips | No AI polishing pass either |
What counts as a Show HN
The Show HN page opens with the core test: "Show HN is for something you've made that other people can play with." On topic means "things people can run on their computers or hold in their hands." Hardware gets an allowance, since "you can post a video or detailed article," and for books "a sample chapter is ok."
The off-topic list is just as specific: "blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters, lists, and other reading material." The page gives the reason in one line, "Those can't be tried out, so can't be Show HNs", and tells you to make a regular submission instead. Further down it adds: "Don't post landing pages or fundraisers."
dang's tips widen the list to "a landing page or market test or fundraiser or a blog post or a curated list or other reading material," and explain why the line is held: "If we allowed 'Show HN' on all those things, nearly every post would be a Show HN."
The project also has to be yours and you have to show up. The guidelines say it "must be something you've worked on personally and which you're around to discuss." It does not have to be polished: "A Show HN needn't be complicated or look slick. The community is comfortable with work that's at an early stage."
Show HN sign-up page not allowed, but a sign-up step is
These are two different rules. A sign-up page as the thing you are posting is off topic. A working product that asks people to register is allowed, but discouraged: the guidelines ask you to make it easy to try "ideally without barriers such as signups or emails," because "You'll get more feedback that way." The tips are blunter, saying "HN users get ornery if you make them jump through hoops."
If you can, ship a guest mode, a public demo account or a sandbox that works without an email address. Skip Show HN entirely if there is nothing to try yet. The guidelines say: "If your work isn't ready for users to try out, please don't do a Show HN. Once it's ready, come back and do it then."
Quickly generated one-offs do not qualify
The guidelines also rule out low-effort projects: "The project should be non-trivial. Don't post quickly-generated one-offs; anybody can do that now." The same paragraph asks for "something that is deeply personal and interesting to you," and tells you to "Explain how and why."
New versions and reposts
Updates have their own bar. The guidelines say "New features and upgrades ('Foo 1.3.1 is out') generally aren't substantive enough to be Show HNs. A major overhaul is probably ok." The tips add that a repost should link to the previous Show HN, explain what changed, and "should probably only happen once or twice a year."
For a post that sank, the FAQ allows "a small number of reposts" of a story that "has not had significant attention in the last year or so." It also says not to delete and repost: "Deletion is for things that shouldn't have been submitted in the first place."
Can I use AI to write my Show HN post?
No. Three separate places say so, at three levels of strictness.
- The site guidelines, for submissions: "Please don't put generated text in HN posts," and, for the same reason, "please don't automate posting."
- The site guidelines, for comments: "Don't post generated text or AI-edited text. HN is for conversation between humans."
- dang's tips, in the edit dated March 28, 2026: "Write your text by hand. Don't use an LLM to generate any of it (not even a tiny bit, including to edit or spruce it up)."
The tips give the reason as community reaction: "LLM language leaves imprints on your text which are generating quite some backlash when it appears on HN itself." They also say what the rule does not cover. HN is not against LLMs: "we use them heavily ourselves," dang writes, adding "Just don't use them to generate or edit text that you post to HN."
Show HN AI generated text rule: what it covers
The rule is about your words, not your code. Building the product with AI coding tools is not what the text rule addresses, though the separate non-trivial rule still applies to what you built. Your title, your post text, your first comment and every reply in the thread are covered. The strictest wording, "not even a tiny bit," is in the tips rather than the guidelines, but both point the same way.
Why was my Show HN flagged?
Flags come from users, and sometimes from moderators. The FAQ says [flagged] means "Users flagged the post as breaking the guidelines or otherwise not belonging on HN," and that moderators sometimes add it too, "though not usually on submissions." A [dead] post "was killed by software, user flags, or moderators," and other users can vouch to restore it once they pass a small karma threshold.
Flags also affect rank. The FAQ lists "user flags, anti-abuse software, software which demotes overheated discussions, account or site weighting, and moderator action" as factors beyond points and time. For a Show HN, the rules above are what a flagger can point to: nothing to try, a landing page, a quick one-off, or text that reads as generated.
Asking for upvotes can get your site penalized
This is where launch habits from other platforms do damage. The Show HN page says "Please don't ask friends to upvote or comment. That's not ok on HN." The FAQ answers "Can I ask people to upvote my submission?" with "No," and states the consequence: "We penalize or ban submissions, accounts, and sites that break this rule."
Asking for comments is covered too, because "HN readers are sensitive to this and will detect it, flag it, and use unkind words like 'spam'." The tips extend this to booster comments from friends and users. A coordinated push, what people call a voting ring, also runs into the software: the FAQ notes that "Some votes are dropped by anti-abuse software."
Other launch boards draw the line elsewhere. On Upfynd, telling your users you are on Upfynd is fine, while buying, trading or organizing votes is not. That difference is why a launch plan built for other launch boards needs a separate HN version with no call to vote.
Other things that read as promotion
- A username that is your company name. The tips say it "creates a feeling of using HN for promotion," and suggest something that shows "you're here as a human, not a brand."
- Marketing copy. "Drop any language that sounds like marketing or sales. On HN, that is an instant turnoff."
- Posting only your own work. The guidelines say "It's ok to post your own stuff part of the time, but the primary use of the site should be for curiosity."
Show HN title format
The only Show HN-specific title rule is that you "submit a story whose title begins with 'Show HN'." The general title rules in the guidelines still apply: no uppercase or exclamation points to make it stand out, no saying how great it is, and drop a gratuitous number. If the link is a video or a PDF, append [video] or [pdf].
The thread that holds dang's tips sits under a post titled "Show HN: Enkel – A clean and simple RSS Reader". It shows the shape that fits those rules: the label, the name, then a plain statement of what the thing is.
How to post on Show HN: the try-it link and the first comment
- Put the try-it link in the URL field. The FAQ says you cannot make a link inside a text submission, and that to share a link with commentary you "submit the link, then add a regular comment."
- Write the text yourself. The tips ask for "the backstory of how you came to work on this," what is different about it, and "a clear statement of what your project is or does," or the thread "will consist of 'I can't tell what this is'."
- Check where the text landed. The tips say it should show at the top of the Show HN; if it doesn't, add it as the first comment.
- Link earlier HN threads about the project. The tips say "Readers like those."
- Remove sign-up barriers for the day, or provide a demo account.
- Use a personal username and, if you are comfortable, put an email in your profile. The tips say HN sometimes uses that address to send a repost invite.
- Be there to answer. Threads stay open for two weeks, after which the FAQ says they are "closed to new comments."
Show HN first comment example: a structure, not a script
Because the text has to be written by hand, a template you paste would defeat the rule. A structure drawn from the tips and guidelines is safer:
- One sentence on what it is or does.
- How you came to build it, in your own words.
- What is different from what already exists, with technical detail.
- What is rough or missing, since the community is "comfortable with work that's at an early stage."
- Links to any previous HN threads.
Best time to post Show HN: there is no official answer
None of the four official pages names a day or hour. What the FAQ does say is how ranking works: "The basic algorithm divides points by a power of the time since a story was submitted," and posts by users with more karma do not rank higher. Every Show HN appears on newest and shownew, and "there is a small points threshold" before it reaches the Show page.
We have not found a dataset published by HN on posting times, so we give none. Pick a time when you can stay in the thread and answer questions, since the guidelines ask for someone "around to discuss."
After Show HN, put the launch where it keeps working
A Show HN thread stops taking comments after two weeks. A directory listing stays up. Listing on Upfynd is free through our submit page, a person checks each submission before it goes live, and launches are ranked by upvotes on daily, weekly and monthly launch boards. Our SEO & Growth category, which includes several launch platforms, held 1,328 products as of November 20, 2026.
Before launch day, run the parts of our SaaS launch checklist that touch your public pages. Then write the HN text by hand, make sure the link works without a sign-up, and post when you can stay in the thread.
Frequently asked questions
What are the Show HN rules?
The Show HN rules say a post must be something you made that people can try now, that you worked on personally and are around to discuss. Blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters, lists, landing pages and fundraisers are off topic. The title starts with Show HN, and you must not ask friends to upvote or comment.
Can I use AI to write my Show HN post?
No. The Hacker News guidelines say not to put generated text in posts or post generated or AI-edited comments. Since an edit dated March 28, 2026, dang's Show HN tips go further: write the text by hand and do not use an LLM for any of it, not even to edit or polish it.
Is a landing page or waitlist allowed on Show HN?
No. The Show HN guidelines say not to post landing pages or fundraisers, and list sign-up pages among things that cannot be tried out. A working product that asks users to register is allowed, but the guidelines ask makers to remove barriers such as signups or emails so more people try it and leave feedback.
Why was my Show HN flagged?
A Show HN is flagged when users decide it breaks the Hacker News guidelines or does not belong on the site. Rule breaks a flagger can point to include having nothing to try, posting a landing page, sharing a quickly generated one-off, text that reads as AI-written, or asking people to upvote. Flags also lower a post's rank.
What is the best time to post a Show HN?
Hacker News publishes no best time to post a Show HN. Its FAQ says ranking divides points by a power of the time since submission, and every Show HN appears on newest and shownew before a small points threshold moves it to the Show page. Post when you can stay and answer questions.
Can I repost a Show HN?
Yes, within limits. The Hacker News FAQ allows a small number of reposts if a story had no significant attention in the last year or so, but not deleting and reposting. For new versions, dang's Show HN tips ask for a significant change, a link to the earlier thread, and reposts only once or twice a year.
About the author
Nihar Rout
CEO & Co-founder